Kiss My HOAss

New York City can fine your co-op or condo board up to $1,250 a day for no heat. File through 311.

HPD's heat and repair rules reach co-ops and condos in Manhattan, Brooklyn, Queens, the Bronx and Staten Island, a sublet unit is outside Good Cause Eviction and rent stabilization, and Local Law 97, facade and gas piping mandates drive your property's bills. Here's what New York City's laws actually give condo unit owners, co-op shareholders and their boards, and what they cost.

The short version

  • HPD's heat rules reach co-ops and condos. From October 1 to May 31: 68°F by day when it's below 55°F outside, and 62°F at night. The Housing Maintenance Code holds responsible anyone "directly or indirectly in control of a dwelling," and heat and hot water violations cost $350 to $1,250 a day. 311 tells co-op and condo residents to report to the owner, management company or board first; then file through 311, and HPD calls the managing agent, sends an inspector if it isn't fixed, and issues violations.
  • If HPD doesn't act, go to Housing Court. If HPD doesn't issue a violation within 30 days of your request, any "lawful occupant" can ask the Housing Part to order the owner and HPD into court. A board of managers, or an aggrieved unit owner, can sue a unit owner to enforce the bylaws and rules (Real Property Law s.339-j).
  • Where to complain: 311 for almost everything (online, app or 212-NEW-YORK): heat and maintenance (HPD), neighbor noise (NYPD) and smoking violations (Health Department). 911 for a crime in progress or a dangerous party.
  • Noise between apartments is covered. Device noise 7 dB(A) over the background level, measured in your apartment, is unreasonable from 10 p.m. to 7 a.m. NYPD answers 311 neighbor-noise calls within 8 hours when it isn't handling emergencies.
  • Another owner's tenant has no special shield. Good Cause Eviction doesn't apply to units in condo or co-op buildings, and rent stabilization doesn't cover buildings owned as a co-op or condo (except tenants left from a conversion). The unit owner can decline to renew a sublet on 30, 60 or 90 days' notice and go to Housing Court; the board can sue the owner. You may use reasonable force to stop a theft.
  • Your board can shut out short-term rentals. Renting for fewer than 30 days needs City registration ($145), and a co-op or condo board can put the whole building on the Prohibited Buildings List.
  • The big bills are City mandates. Local Law 97 emissions penalties run up to $268 a ton a year. Facade inspections come every five years ($1,000 a month if late), gas piping inspections every four ($5,000 if missed), and elevator tests every year ($3,000 to $5,000 for a missed filing).
  • Parking and towing, at the bottom of this page: your board can tow without the police. The property owner contracts with a DCWP-licensed tow company, posts the required signs and signs a written authorization for each car: no ticket, no officer, no waiting period. The driver pays at most $125 for the tow and three days' storage, then $15 a day. One catch: the authorization must list the car's license plate number. For a car with no plates abandoned on your property, DSNY will remove it on written request for a fee "based on the price of scrap metal"; no amount is published. A pay lot gets no special protection.

When your board won't fix things

  • The Housing Maintenance Code reaches your building. It covers dwellings, including multiple dwellings of three or more households, and its definitions don't exclude co-ops or condos. The "owner" it holds responsible includes anyone "directly or indirectly in control of a dwelling" (s.27-2004).
  • Heat: October 1 to May 31, 68°F from 6 a.m. to 10 p.m. when it's below 55°F outside, and 62°F overnight whatever the weather (s.27-2029). State law requires only 55°F at night, and only when it's below 40°F (Multiple Dwelling Law s.79).
  • Hot water: at least 120°F (s.27-2031).
  • Getting HPD to act against your board: 311 tells co-op and condo residents to report to the owner, management company or board first, because "the specific agreements between the coop or condo owner and the board may dictate" who must fix a condition. Then file through 311: HPD calls the managing agent, sends an inspector if it isn't fixed, and issues violations.
  • Penalties: heat and hot water violations cost $350 to $1,250 a day, and $500 to $1,500 for a repeat. HPD gives no correction time for heat. Most other immediately hazardous violations: 24 hours; hazardous: 30 days; non-hazardous: 90 days.
  • Housing Court: if HPD doesn't issue a violation within 30 days of your request, or one is outstanding, any "lawful occupant" can ask the Housing Part to order the owner and HPD into court (s.27-2115(h)).
  • One thing you don't get: the Code's tenant-harassment remedies don't apply where a shareholder or condo owner of record lives in the unit (s.27-2115(n)). Their tenants keep them.

Where to complain

  • 311 (online, app or 212-NEW-YORK) for heat and maintenance (HPD), neighbor noise (NYPD), unplated abandoned cars (DSNY), tows and boots (DCWP) and smoking violations (Health Department).
  • In writing to DSNY for private-property removal of an unplated car.
  • 911 for a crime in progress or a dangerous party.
  • Timelines: NYPD noise within 8 hours when free; DSNY street tags within three business days; HPD calls the managing agent, then inspects; DCWP mails or emails you a complaint form. If HPD doesn't act in 30 days, Housing Court. If DEP doesn't act on a sworn noise complaint in 30 days, you can prosecute it.

Neighbors, tenants and short-term rentals

Noise

  • The rule: no "unreasonable noise," meaning sound that disturbs "a reasonable person of normal sensitivities" (Administrative Code ss.24-203, 24-218).
  • It reaches inside your building. Your apartment can be a "receiving property." Device noise is unreasonable at 7 dB(A) over the background level from 10 p.m. to 7 a.m., 10 dB(A) from 7 a.m. to 10 p.m., and 15 dB(A) for impulsive sound, measured in the receiving property (s.24-218(b)).
  • Music and dogs: no stereo, TV or instrument used to make unreasonable noise (s.24-244). A dog or other animal plainly audible in your home 10 minutes straight by day, or 5 minutes at night, breaks the law (s.24-235).
  • Renovations: construction only on weekdays, 7 a.m. to 6 p.m., unless authorized (s.24-222).
  • Fines, first offense: $75 to $150 for unreasonable noise; $440 to $1,750 for a sound device; $50 to $175 for an animal; $875 to $3,500 for after-hours construction. Repeat offenses cost more.
  • Who to call: 311. For a noisy neighbor, NYPD responds "within 8 hours when they are not handling emergencies" and can act only if the noise is still going on. 311 also points you to your co-op's or condo's rules and free mediation.
  • Do it yourself: for some violations, including sound devices, you can file a sworn complaint with the Department of Environmental Protection; if it doesn't act within 30 days, you can bring the case yourself and share in the penalty (s.24-261).

When another owner's tenant causes trouble

The claim we tested: "If a tenant is stealing your shit, even if it is someone else's tenant, you aren't allowed to stop them." Wrong in New York.

  • You can stop a theft. Anyone may use physical force, short of deadly force, to the extent reasonably necessary to prevent or end what they reasonably believe is larceny or criminal mischief (Penal Law s.35.25). Anyone may arrest a person for an offense committed in their presence (Criminal Procedure Law s.140.30). 911 for a crime in progress.
  • Good Cause Eviction doesn't protect the sublet. The 2024 law applies in New York City (Real Property Law s.212), but not to a "unit on or within a housing accommodation owned as a condominium or cooperative" (s.214(7)). HPD's page lists "Homes in condo and co-op buildings" as exempt.
  • Neither does rent stabilization. It covers buildings "not owned as a cooperative or as a condominium" (Administrative Code s.26-504(a)). The exception is a tenant left from a conversion; a person who sublets from a buyer isn't one (General Business Law s.352-eeee(1)(e)).
  • So the owner can end it. A unit owner or shareholder renting out an apartment gives written notice of non-renewal: 30 days if the tenant has been there under a year, 60 for one to two years, 90 for longer (Real Property Law s.226-c). Then a holdover in Housing Court.
  • How fast: the petition is served 10 to 17 days before the hearing (RPAPL s.733). The court can stay eviction up to a year for hardship, but not where the landlord proves the occupant "is objectionable" (s.753(3)); a lease-breach case gets a 30-day stay to cure (s.753(4)). A marshal gives 14 days' notice (s.749).
  • The board's routes. A board of managers, or an aggrieved unit owner, can sue the unit owner to enforce the bylaws and rules (Real Property Law s.339-j). A co-op that ends a proprietary lease under an "objectionable" clause must prove it in court (RPAPL s.711(1)). In the City, a tenant's conviction under the Housing Maintenance Code for serious damage or repeated interference with others is a ground for eviction (Administrative Code s.27-2009).
  • Neighbors can force a case for illegal use. An owner or tenant within 200 feet of premises used for an illegal business can demand that the landlord start removal; if the landlord doesn't within five days, the neighbor can bring the case (RPAPL s.715).
  • No lockouts. Removing anyone who has lived in a unit 30 days or more, or has a lease, without a court warrant is a misdemeanor with a civil penalty of $1,000 to $10,000 (Administrative Code s.26-521; RPAPL s.768).
  • NYPD policy: officers summons or arrest for unlawful evictions (Patrol Guide P.G. 214-12), and refer non-criminal neighbor disputes, including noise that breaks no code and non-criminal damage, to community mediation (P.G. 214-40).

Partly right: neither the board nor a neighbor can remove the tenant directly. It takes the unit's owner, the co-op's lease termination, or a court.

Short-term rentals

  • Registration: renting for fewer than 30 days requires registration with the Mayor's Office of Special Enforcement under Local Law 18 of 2022. Only a permanent occupant of the unit, its owner or a tenant whose lease allows it, can register. Fee: $145. Rent-regulated units can't be registered. Booking sites can't process unregistered rentals.
  • Your co-op's or condo's rules still win: a registration isn't permission for a use that breaks "a lease, cooperative bylaws, condominium association rules and regulations" (s.26-3102(g)).
  • Boards can shut the door. A co-op or condo board can put the whole building on the Prohibited Buildings List by certifying that every unit's lease or occupancy agreement bans short-term rentals. The City must then deny registrations, and can move to revoke existing ones at OATH.
  • Penalties: an unregistered rental, up to $5,000 or three times the revenue, whichever is less; other host violations, up to $5,000.
  • State law underneath: apartments in a class A multiple dwelling are for stays of 30 days or more (Multiple Dwelling Law s.4(8)).

Smoking and vaping

  • Common areas: no smoking or vaping of any substance in indoor common areas of buildings with three or more units, such as hallways, stairwells, lobbies and laundry rooms, with signs required. Apartments aren't covered.
  • Every building needs a policy (Local Law 147 of 2017). It must cover units, balconies, rooftops and courtyards, and be shared with residents every year. A condo's board of managers must put it in the bylaws or rules; a co-op's board, in its bylaws or rules; and a unit owner or shareholder must include it in any rental or sale agreement. Fine: $100.
  • It doesn't have to ban anything, and it doesn't bind a tenant mid-lease or a rent-regulated tenant already in place. The Health Department won't enforce a building's policy; the building does.

Local rules that cost your co-op or condo money

LawWho it hitsDeadlinePenalty
Local Law 97 (emissions)Buildings over 25,000 sq ft, or condo buildings under one board over 50,000Report every May 1; next May 1, 2027, for 2026Up to $268 per ton over the limit, per year; late report up to $0.50 per sq ft a month
Facade inspections (FISP)Buildings over six storiesCycle 10: block numbers ending 4, 5, 6, 9 by Feb 21, 2027; 0, 7, 8 by Feb 21, 2028; 1, 2, 3 by Feb 21, 2029$1,000 a month late; $5,000 a year if never filed; $1,000 a month plus $10 to $40 per foot of sidewalk shed for unsafe conditions not fixed in 90 days
Gas piping (Local Law 152)All but one- and two-family homesCommunity districts 4, 6, 8, 9, 16 by Dec 31, 2026; 11, 12, 14, 15, 17 in 2027$5,000 for not filing
ElevatorsEvery elevatorPeriodic inspection and Category 1 test every year; Category 5 every five yearsBuildings with 3+ homes: $150 a month late (up to $1,800), $3,000 for not filing; Category 5: $250 a month, $5,000

The residential emissions limit drops from 0.00675 to 0.00407 tons per square foot in 2030. A court weighs good-faith efforts and financial hardship in setting the emissions penalty (s.28-320.6.1).

What's statewide and what's NYC

Statewide (the same law all over New York, even where a statute applies only to the largest cities): the condominium compliance action (Real Property Law s.339-j); Good Cause Eviction and its condo and co-op exemption; Housing Court procedure (notice periods, stays, the marshal's notice); a neighbor's right to force an illegal-use case; the ban on self-help evictions; reasonable force and citizen's arrest; the 30-day rule for apartment buildings; the Clean Indoor Air Act; the state heat minimum; abandoned-vehicle law (96 hours on private property; City title to a junk car with no plates); the towing lien.

New York City only: the Housing Maintenance Code and HPD enforcement; the Noise Code; rent stabilization's co-op and condo exclusion; short-term rental registration and the Prohibited Buildings List; the indoor common-area smoking rule and the smoking-policy law; Local Law 97 and the facade, gas piping and elevator mandates; the private-property towing and booting rules and their fee caps; DCWP garage licensing; DSNY's removal of unplated cars from private property.

Where New York City differs inside itself

  • Almost nowhere. The towing, garage, booting, noise, housing maintenance, smoking, short-term rental and building-mandate rules on this page are the same in all five boroughs.
  • Staten Island tows: if your car was towed for illegal parking in Staten Island, 311 sends you to the local precinct instead of the NYPD tow-pound lookup.
  • Unlawful eviction summonses go to Manhattan Criminal Court for Manhattan, the Bronx, Brooklyn and Queens, and to Staten Island Criminal Court for Staten Island.
  • Gas piping year depends on your community district; the facade window depends on the last digit of your tax block number.

Local limits

Six City rules add a burden, ranked by cost:

  1. Local Law 97. Up to $268 a ton over the limit every year. The State's energy code governs construction.
  2. Facade inspections. A full exterior examination every five years and penalties from $1,000 a month.
  3. Gas piping inspections. A plumber's inspection every four years; $5,000 for missing it.
  4. Unplated junk cars. State law gives the City ownership of an unplated abandoned car worth $2,250 or less, yet the City charges the property owner to remove one and asks for a waiver.
  5. Towing conditions. Your board can tow without police, but only with a contract, prescribed signs and a signed form for each car.
  6. The smoking-policy law. A $100 fine for failing to adopt or share a policy.

Not on this list: Good Cause Eviction (state law, and condos and co-ops are exempt), the 30-day lockout rule (the same in state law), the City's heat standard (it protects residents), and short-term rental registration (the rest of the state has its own registry).

Parking and towing

A car with no plates in your stall

Will the City take it? Yes, on request. 311 says you can ask DSNY "to remove a vehicle without license plates that was abandoned by someone else on your private property." You must sign a waiver, make the vehicle accessible, pay a fee based on the price of scrap metal, and write to Derelict Vehicle Removal, Department of Sanitation, Central Correspondence Unit, 59 Maiden Lane, 5th Floor, New York, NY 10038. A car the property owner owns doesn't qualify.

Which cars? DSNY treats a vehicle as derelict when it has no license plate and is damaged and worth less than $2,250. Its page states that test for cars abandoned on public property; the 311 private-property instructions don't repeat it. An intact car whose plates were taken off may not fit.

How long must you wait? Neither page sets a wait. State law calls a car left more than 96 hours on someone else's property without permission "abandoned," and if it has no plates and is worth $2,250 or less, ownership vests in the City immediately (Vehicle and Traffic Law s.1224(1)(d), (2)). On a street, DSNY tags a derelict car within three business days. No response time is published for private property.

Can a contract tow take it instead? The law lets your board tow any improperly parked car under a contract (below), but the written authorization for each tow "shall include the location, make, model, color and license plate number" (s.19-169.1(c); the DCWP rule, 6 RCNY s.2-377(h), adds date, time and signer). The text doesn't say what to do when there's no plate.

Plates that don't trace: a car that bears a plate can be towed like any other, because the plate number goes on the form. Police remove registration plates that expired more than two months ago and issue a summons, and an abandoned car goes to the rotation tow program at NYPD's direction (NYPD Patrol Guide P.G. 214-30; Administrative Code s.20-519).

Who can ask: the owner of the property, or the agent named in the tow contract. Neither text says who signs for a condominium's common elements, or whether an individual unit owner can sign for a stall.

If it can't be moved: if the car belongs to a unit owner, the board of managers, or an aggrieved unit owner, can sue for damages or an injunction (Real Property Law s.339-j). In a co-op, the proprietary lease governs. Whoever abandoned the car faces a $250 to $1,000 fine, plus a City civil penalty of the same range (VTL s.1224(7)).

The claim we tested: that a driver who takes the plates off "is effectively allowed to steal your parking stall forever." Mostly wrong in New York City. The City will haul away an unplated car abandoned on private property, and your board can tow without police. Partly right: you pay DSNY, and an intact car with its plates removed may fall between DSNY's junk-car test and a tow form that asks for a plate number.

Parking and towing on your property

  • No City ticket for your stall. The traffic rules' only private-property parking rule is blocking a driveway (34 RCNY s.4-08(f)(2)). Parking in a condo lot without consent isn't a City violation; the remedy is a tow or a boot.
  • The board's own tow: contract with a DCWP-licensed tow company; post signs at each vehicle entry and at least every 250 feet of perimeter, with "WARNING!" in red letters at least 5 inches high, "PRIVATE PARKING LOT," "VEHICLES SUBJECT TO TOWING," the conditions, the tow company, its fees and redemption hours (which must run 60 minutes past the last towing hour); sign a written authorization for each car (s.19-169.1; 6 RCNY s.2-377).
  • Caps: $125 for removal and three days' storage, then $15 a day. If the driver shows up while the car is hooked, it must be released for half the removal charge (311 lists the "drop fee" as $62.50). Tow companies must take credit cards.
  • Where it goes: straight to the tow company's secure lot inside the city, no more than 10 miles away. The tow company must call the local precinct within 30 minutes of arrival.
  • Get it wrong and you pay. A car towed in violation costs the driver nothing, and the owner, its agent or the tow company is liable for what was paid and any damage. Fines: $500, then $1,000 (s.19-169.1(i), (j)).
  • One NYPD caution: the Patrol Guide's driveway procedure says "Administrative Code 19-169.1 does not permit owners/lessees of the same property to have this statute enforced against each other" (P.G. 214-14). The Code itself has no such exception, and the Guide doesn't say how it applies to a condominium's co-owners.
  • Blocked driveways: the separate driveway tow law covers only lots with two or fewer homes (s.19-169).
  • Complaints about tows and boots go to DCWP through 311.

Pay parking and towing

The claim we tested in Toronto: a condo that runs public pay parking can never tow a car that paid. In Toronto a car that paid can't be towed for its paid time. New York City has no such rule.

  • License: a garage or outdoor lot that holds five or more vehicles and charges "directly or indirectly" needs a DCWP license, $300 to $690 every two years by size (Administrative Code ss.20-320, 20-321). A garage run by a building's owner exclusively for its residents is exempt (s.20-322(c)); one that also serves the public isn't run exclusively for residents.
  • No pay-lot towing limit: the garage and parking lot chapter (ss.20-320 to 20-332) and DCWP's garage rule (6 RCNY s.2-161) say nothing about towing, and no City rule says payment is consent. Section 19-169.1 covers "parking facilities on private property" generally, so the usual contract, sign and authorization rules apply.
  • Abandoned cars in a licensed garage: the operator must report any transient vehicle left unclaimed more than 72 hours to the Police Commissioner, and every 30 days after (6 RCNY s.2-161(f)(2)). A licensed lot must be attended whenever it's open.
  • Boots: a boot must come off within 30 minutes of a request, and the charge can't exceed what the signs say. The $25 cap applies only to a free customer lot, which the Code defines as one "provided to the public without charge" (ss.19-169.2, 20-531(b)(3), 20-535).
  • Occupied vehicles: a tow company may not remove a vehicle with anyone in it, and no one may boot a car with a person or animal inside (ss.19-169.1(d), 19-169.2(d)). Call police.

How New York City compares

New York CityToronto
City takes complaints about an owner-occupied unitYes, through 311 and HPDNo
Minimum heat at night62°F, October 1 to May 3121°C, rented units only
Night noise limit inside your unitDevice noise 7 dB(A) over background, 10 p.m. to 7 a.m.42 dB(A) amplified sound, 11 p.m. to 7 a.m.
Evicting another owner's tenantThrough the unit owner or the co-op, in Housing Court; Good Cause and rent stabilization don't applyOnly the landlord, through the Landlord and Tenant Board
Short-term rentalsHost must live there and register ($145); buildings can opt outPrincipal residence, 180 nights for a whole unit, $390
Ticket for parking in a condo stall without consentNone; tow or boot instead$75
Who can tow from condo propertyThe board, under a contract with a DCWP-licensed tow company, with posted signsPolice, or a licensed agency at a Chief-approved property, with a police tow card
Tow and storage cap$125 for the tow and three days, then $15 a dayToronto Police Service contract rate
Car with no plates in your stallDSNY removes it on the owner's written request, for a feeTowed with police authorization, no ticket
Pay lot: can a car that paid be towed?No special rule; normal tow rules applyNo, for its paid time

Paid for them already? Send them to us.

Upload your property's documents. We'll post what the law allows, free, with owner names, unit numbers and other personal information removed, so the next owner, buyer or neighbor never pays again. Then we'll run the Smell Test on your property.

Sources

  1. New York City Administrative Code and Rules of the City of New York
  2. Administrative Code ss.19-169 to 19-169.2, private property towing and booting
  3. Administrative Code Title 20, Chapter 2: garages and parking lots, towing, booting
  4. 6 RCNY Chapter 2: DCWP rules on garages (s.2-161) and towing (ss.2-361 to 2-378)
  5. 34 RCNY Chapter 4: Traffic Rules, s.4-08
  6. Administrative Code Title 24, Chapter 2: Noise Control
  7. Administrative Code Title 27, Chapter 2: Housing Maintenance Code
  8. Administrative Code Title 26, Chapter 4: Rent Stabilization and Chapter 5: Unlawful Eviction
  9. Administrative Code Title 26, Chapter 31: Short-Term Rentals and 43 RCNY Chapter 21
  10. Administrative Code Title 17, Chapter 5: Smoke-Free Air Act
  11. Administrative Code Title 28, Chapter 3: Maintenance of Buildings
  12. 1 RCNY s.103-04, facade inspections and 1 RCNY s.103-02, elevators
  13. DOB, LL97 Greenhouse Gas Emissions Violations
  14. DOB, Facade Fees and Penalties and FISP Cycle 10 service notice
  15. DOB, Gas Piping Inspection
  16. DOB, Elevator Compliance
  17. NYC311, Abandoned Vehicle, Towed Vehicle, Blocked Driveway and Tow Truck Complaint
  18. NYC311, Noise from Neighbor, Heat or Hot Water Complaint and Apartment Maintenance Complaint
  19. DSNY, Derelict Vehicles
  20. DCWP, Towing Services Guide
  21. HPD, Penalties and Fees and Good Cause Eviction
  22. Office of Special Enforcement, Registration, Prohibited Buildings List and Enforcement
  23. NYC Health, Smoke-Free Air Act factsheet and Disclosure of Policies on Smoking
  24. NYPD Public Patrol Guide, Part 3 (P.G. 214-12, 214-14, 214-30, 214-40)
  25. Real Property Law Article 6-A, Good Cause Eviction, s.226-b, s.226-c, s.231 and s.339-j
  26. Real Property Actions and Proceedings Law ss.711, 715, 733, 749, 753 and 768
  27. Vehicle and Traffic Law s.1224 and s.1642; Lien Law s.184
  28. Penal Law s.35.25 and Criminal Procedure Law s.140.30
  29. General Business Law s.352-eeee
  30. Multiple Dwelling Law s.4, s.79 and s.121; Real Property Law Article 12-D
  31. Public Health Law s.1399-o
  32. Executive Law s.383 and Energy Law s.11-104

Current as of October 31, 2026. This is general information, not legal advice. Laws change, and the online Administrative Code and Rules can lag new local laws; check the current text on the City's code site, nyc.gov and the State Senate's Open Legislation site before relying on a specific figure, and talk to a lawyer about your own situation.