Why it's sweaty
The three things that cost Example Court the most points.
- Reserve contributions are $70,000 a year, 67% of what the reserve study recommends, and today's fund plus ten years of contributions covers 82% of the planned work. Budget 2026, p.2 Reserve fund study 2021, p.18
- Leaks and building envelope problems keep coming back in the minutes, and the windows are due in 2031 and 2032: about $3,750 a unit in levies in 2032 at today's contributions. Reserve fund study 2021, p.22
- Operating fees, leaving out the reserve contribution, are 21% higher than at similar properties. Budget 2026, p.1
How we got 61
Six parts, 100 points, each built from measures in the property's own documents. A formula scores the facts; nobody's opinion moves a number. Then the municipality costs points where its own rules take away what owners can do elsewhere.
- 9 of 17 Funding level: today's balance plus 10 years of today's contributions covers 82% of the study's planned spending.
- 0 of 4 Contributions: $70,000 a year, 67% of the $105,000 the study recommends.
- 2 of 4 Study and the law: the study is 5 years old; Alberta requires a new one every 5 years, with no waiver.
- 4 of 8 Levy outlook: about $4,391 a unit over 10 years, 71% of a year's fees; the largest is $3,750 in 2032.
- 4 of 8 Property condition: leaks and building envelope recorded at 3 or more meetings with no completed repair, which counts as a major component overdue.
- 4 of 4 Past assessments: none in the last 5 years. The windows levy under discussion is counted in the outlook, not again here.
- 2 of 3 Litigation: an owner's court claim over a deductible chargeback.
- 2 of 2 Debt: no loans.
- 8 of 15 Operating fees, leaving out the reserve contribution: $5,125 a unit a year, 21% above the middle of 14 similar properties ($4,250).
- 5 of 7 Chargeable deductible: owners pay up to the full $50,000 water deductible when damage starts in their unit.
- 0 of 2 Against similar properties: twice their $25,000.
- 2 of 2 Shared catastrophe deductible (hail): $391 a unit, against $420 at similar properties.
- 2 of 2 Coverage: insured to replacement value, appraisal current, changes disclosed at the AGM.
- 2 of 2 Arrears: 1% of fee revenue.
- 7 of 7 Fee growth: 3.3% a year, against 3.9% at similar properties (3.0% inflation).
- 3 of 3 Operating result: balanced last year.
- 2 of 4 Records and Fee Watch: the manager charged $170 over the legal price for documents.
- 3 of 3 Governance: AGMs 12 months apart (Alberta allows 15), minutes complete, licensed manager (new since July 2025).
- 3 of 3 Financial statements: audited, clean and on time, as the corporation's bylaws require (Alberta's Act asks for neither an audit nor a review).
- minus 2 A remedy narrowed. Edmonton Parking Enforcement will not remove a derelict, wrecked or dismantled vehicle from private property.
- minus 1 A burden added. City enforcement on private property depends on signs that meet Edmonton's standard (two signs per entrance, about 60 by 60 cm, reflective, set wording); the City will not ticket or tow where signs name a tow company or show an outdated fine.
Six parts: 64. Every property in Edmonton loses these 3 points, because the City's own rules narrow what owners can do about their property. These limits are real, checked against the City's bylaws: read the Edmonton guide.
Scored with the Smell Test rubric, draft v0.5, which is being tested on real properties before any real score is published. n/a: not scored.
Against similar properties
Per unit, against the middle of the comparison group.
Reserve contributions
▼ -19%
$1,094 a unit a year. Less going in than at similar properties.
Budget 2026, p.2Insurance premium
▲ +48%
Up 22% at the last renewal, after two water claims.
Insurance certificate 2026, p.1Water deductible
▲ +100%
$50,000. What an owner can be charged when a leak starts in their unit.
Insurance certificate 2026, p.2Compared with 14 Edmonton apartment-style condominiums built 1994 to 2004, 3 to 4 storeys, 40 to 90 units.
Levy outlook
What the reserve fund study plans to spend, what's in the fund, and what owners may be asked to pay on top of their fees.
| Year | Biggest item | Planned spending | Fund at year end | Shortfall | Per unit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 2026 | Asphalt and concrete patching | $38,000 | $444,000 | None | None |
| 2027 | Exterior lighting | $22,000 | $492,000 | None | None |
| 2028 | Roof replacement | $410,000 | $152,000 | None | None |
| 2029 | Balcony membranes | $64,000 | $158,000 | None | None |
| 2030 | Fencing | $18,000 | $210,000 | None | None |
| 2031 | Windows and patio doors, phase 1 | $296,000 | $0 | $16,000 | $250 |
| 2032 | Windows and patio doors, phase 2 | $310,000 | $0 | $240,000 | $3,750 |
| 2033 | Hallway carpet | $45,000 | $25,000 | None | None |
| 2034 | Elevator modernization | $120,000 | $0 | $25,000 | $390 |
| 2035 | Parkade sealing | $30,000 | $40,000 | None | None |
Starting from $412,000 in the fund (December 31, 2025) and $70,000 a year going in. Avoiding every levy would take about $106,600 a year, or about $48 more a unit a month. Reserve fund study 2021, p.22
Red flags from the minutes
Every mention, by topic, with the date and the page. Names and unit numbers are removed.
Leaks6
- May 12, 2026 Parkade membrane leaking over stalls along the north wall. Contractor to quote. Board minutes, May 2026, p.2
- Mar 10, 2026 Water entering a top-floor suite during spring melt. Roofer attended. Board minutes, Mar 2026, p.1
- Nov 18, 2025 Insurance claim of about $78,000 for a failed pipe. Deductible charged back to the suite's owner. Board minutes, Nov 2025, p.3
- Sep 16, 2025 Dryer vent leaking into a third-floor hallway ceiling. Board minutes, Sep 2025, p.2
- Jun 10, 2025 Window leaks reported in four suites after a storm. Board minutes, Jun 2025, p.2
- Feb 11, 2025 Parkade drain backed up. Drain lines flushed. Board minutes, Feb 2025, p.1
Building envelope3
- Apr 14, 2026 Engineer hired to assess windows after more seal failures on the west face. Board minutes, Apr 2026, p.2
- Oct 21, 2025 Stucco cracking at the southeast corner noted at the walk-around. Board minutes, Oct 2025, p.2
- Jun 10, 2025 Window seal failures; owners asked to report fogged panes. Board minutes, Jun 2025, p.3
Roof2
- Mar 10, 2026 Roofer says the roof is near the end of its life; patching for now. Board minutes, Mar 2026, p.1
- Aug 19, 2025 Patch repairs over the stairwell. Board minutes, Aug 2025, p.2
Special assessment talk1
- May 12, 2026 Board discussed whether a special assessment will be needed for the windows. Board minutes, May 2026, p.3
Insurance2
- Jan 13, 2026 Renewal: premium up 22%; water deductible raised from $25,000 to $50,000. Board minutes, Jan 2026, p.1
- Dec 9, 2025 Broker warns that more water claims will raise the deductible again. Board minutes, Dec 2025, p.2
Legal and disputes1
- Feb 10, 2026 An owner started a court claim over a deductible chargeback. Board minutes, Feb 2026, p.2
Management1
- Jun 10, 2025 New management company from July 2025. Board minutes, Jun 2025, p.4
Security1
- Oct 21, 2025 Parkade break-in; two storage lockers emptied. Board minutes, Oct 2025, p.3
The bylaws, in short
What owners and tenants can and can't do. Not scored; check the current bylaws before you rely on this.
Rentals
Allowed with leases of 6 months or more. No short-term rentals (Airbnb, VRBO). $200 rental deposit.
Bylaws (2019), p.27Age
No age limits found.
Water damage
Owners pay up to the full $50,000 water deductible when damage starts in their unit.
Bylaws (2019), p.31Insurance
The deductible is what the corporation pays before insurance does, and it's what an owner can be charged when damage starts in their unit.
| Peril | Example Court | Similar properties |
|---|---|---|
| Water damage | $50,000 | $25,000 |
| Sewer backup | $50,000 | $25,000 |
| Hail | $25,000 | $25,000 |
| All other perils | $10,000 | $10,000 |
The budget, line by line
Per unit per year. Shaded red: more than 15% worse than similar properties (higher spending, or a smaller reserve contribution). Green: more than 15% better.
| Line | Example Court | Similar properties | Difference |
|---|---|---|---|
| Management feesAdministration | $594 | $500 | +19% |
| Audit and accountingAdministration | $56 | $52 | +8% |
| LegalAdministration | $23 | $18 | +30% |
| Office and bank chargesAdministration | $14 | $15 | -6% |
| Insurance premiumInsurance | $1,844 | $1,250 | +48% |
| ElectricityUtilities | $344 | $330 | +4% |
| Gas (heat)Utilities | $469 | $420 | +12% |
| Water and sewerUtilities | $312 | $300 | +4% |
| Property repairsRepairs and maintenance | $375 | $420 | -11% |
| Elevator contractRepairs and maintenance | $150 | $150 | 0% |
| JanitorialRepairs and maintenance | $225 | $210 | +7% |
| Landscaping and snowRepairs and maintenance | $281 | $260 | +8% |
| Fire safetyRepairs and maintenance | $75 | $70 | +7% |
| Mechanical and HVACRepairs and maintenance | $97 | $90 | +8% |
| Window cleaningRepairs and maintenance | $47 | $40 | +17% |
| Pest controlRepairs and maintenance | $16 | $15 | +4% |
| Garbage and recyclingRepairs and maintenance | $141 | $140 | 0% |
| Reserve fund contributionReserve fund | $1,094 | $1,350 | -19% |
| ContingencyOther | $62 | $40 | +56% |
- Management fees: about $6,000 a year more than similar properties would spend.
- Insurance premium: about $38,000 a year more than similar properties would spend.
Fees, average a unit a month: 2021: $440 → 2022: $452 → 2023: $468 → 2024: $487 → 2025: $503 → 2026: $518. That's up 18% in five years; similar properties are up 21%.
Fee Watch
What the manager charged an owner for the documents behind this page, against the price the law allows.
Charged by Example Management Ltd.
11 documents by email and the information statement
The legal price
11 documents at $10 and the information statement at $100
Documents used
This score uses only these. Send what's missing or out of date and the score updates.
Used
- Budget 2026, approved Nov 2025
- Financial statements 2025, audited, Mar 2026
- Reserve fund report Dec 2025
- Insurance certificate Jan 2026
- Bylaws consolidated Aug 2019
- Rules 2022
- AGM minutes Nov 2025
- Board minutes 12 meetings, Jan 2025 to May 2026
Out of date
- Reserve fund study May 2021. Over five years old; a new one is due. Send a newer one
Missing
- Information statement The corporation's own disclosure for a sale. Send it
- Engineering report on the windows Ordered in April 2026, per the minutes. Send it
- Insurance policy The full wording, not just the certificate. Send it
- Management agreement What the manager is paid to do, and for how much. Send it
The property
- Plan
- Condominium Plan 000 0000
- Type
- Wood-frame apartment
- Units
- 64
- Storeys
- 4
- Built
- 1998
- Average unit
- 820 sq ft
- Heat
- Included in fees (shared gas boiler)
- Parking
- Underground, one stall per unit
- Median suite assessment (city)
- $205,000 in 2022 to $226,000 in 2026
- Fees
- $518 a unit a month
The board's reply
The Smell Test is our opinion, based only on the documents listed above. It isn't advice, and it isn't a recommendation to buy or not to buy.
Want this for your property?
Upload whatever documents you have: budgets, minutes, the reserve fund study, the insurance certificate. We post them free with personal details removed, so the next owner never pays for them, and you get your property's Smell Test first.